Yahoo Finance editor Janna Herron debunks some personal finance spending myths and explains how purchase shaming can be harmful.
– Welcome back. Do you ever get any unsolicited personal finance advice saying, don’t buy this phone? Don’t buy this Starbucks latte. Instead, save for your retirement. Use this. Put this in an emergency fund. Well, this could actually be bad advice even if well-intentioned. And here to tell us about it is Yahoo Finance’s Janna Herron. And Janna, this sounds like good news to me because this used to be a real kind of pet peeve of mine.
JANNA HERRON: Yeah, so it definitely can be well-meaning, this kind of advice. You know, it simplifies personal finance so it’s not daunting like you said. Save $20 or $30 by not buying this or that. And voila. Decades down the road, you have tens of thousands of dollars for retirement. But I think it misses the forest for the trees.
First, it really focuses on those small purchases rather than the real budget-busting items like housing, child care, health care, all of which have been outpacing wages for years. And even though we’re seeing wage growth, it’s not enough to make up for it, especially with inflation now, increasing costs of basic items like food and gas. So those costs of those really– those bigger items are the real culprits that are holding back people’s financial security and aren’t easily solved by simply avoiding them or cutting them out. It’s not very easy to cut out your housing like it is a latte.
Second, I feel like this type of advice– and I like to call it purchase shaming– perpetuates the idea that those who don’t earn as much can’t manage their money. And that’s not true according to experts I’ve talked to who work with working-class Americans. They simply don’t have a lot to work with. And they’re not really spending foolishly. They make a lot of sacrifices and a lot of trade-offs that those of us who earn more than they do don’t have to make. One expert I talked to even said they earn an MBA equivalent just by dealing with their finances.
And then last– I think this is the most damaging– is this subtext that this kind of advice gives is that those who earn less or those who are poor …….